Saylorsburg sits toward the eastern edge of Monroe County, closer to the Northampton County line than towns like Tobyhanna or Cresco. That position gives it a somewhat different profile — here’s what living in Saylorsburg is actually like.
New to the idea of the Poconos generally? Start with Living in the Poconos: The Complete Guide, or compare Saylorsburg to Stroudsburg.
What Makes Saylorsburg Different
Saylorsburg’s eastern Monroe County location, near Route 33, puts it within easier reach of the Lehigh Valley than many other Poconos communities. It has a quieter, more rural character than Stroudsburg, without the resort orientation of Tannersville.
Housing in Saylorsburg
Housing in Saylorsburg tends toward standard residential and rural properties. Based on local MLS/PMAR data, Saylorsburg’s average sale price over the trailing 19 months (Jan 2025–Jul 2026) has been $386,615, with a March 2026 snapshot of $367,967 — running above the Monroe County-wide average, among the stronger price points of the towns tracked in local MLS data.
Schools and Commute
As with the rest of Monroe County, effective property tax rates run above the Pennsylvania state average — commonly cited around 2.4%. Pennsylvania’s flat 3.07% income tax rate can meaningfully offset that difference for buyers coming from New Jersey or New York — see the full breakdown in the Living in the Poconos guide. Saylorsburg’s proximity to Route 33 gives it a genuine commute advantage toward the Lehigh Valley compared to towns further into the mountains — worth factoring in if commute time is a priority.
Everyday Life
Saylorsburg is quieter and more rural, with fewer local commercial amenities than Stroudsburg or Mount Pocono. Residents typically drive to nearby towns, including into the Lehigh Valley, for larger shopping and services.
Who Saylorsburg Fits Best
Saylorsburg tends to suit buyers who want a genuine commute advantage toward the Lehigh Valley along with a quieter, more rural setting. If walkable downtown amenities matter more, Stroudsburg is likely a better fit. See Best Places to Live in the Poconos for the full comparison.
Thinking About Saylorsburg?
I work throughout Monroe County, including Saylorsburg’s commuter-friendly, rural properties. If you’re weighing Saylorsburg against other parts of the Poconos, I’d be glad to walk you through the specifics. Start browsing listings, or get in touch directly to talk it through.
Sources: MLS/PMAR (Pocono Mountains Association of Realtors) sales data, U.S. Census data on Monroe County municipalities, SmartAsset and Ownwell property tax analyses. Figures are approximate and change over time — contact us for current, property-specific numbers.